Moger, Susan Of Better
Blood 285 pages. Albert Whitman and
Company, 2016. Language: G (0 swears); Mature Content: R (human
sterilization); Violence: R (murder).
It is 1922, and Rowan Collier, 16, has lost the use of one
of her legs to polio. Her disability is
a shame to her wealthy, high-bred father, who has abandoned her to
institutional care. While there, she is
selected to act out a role in the “Unfit Family Show”, a scripted play
illustrating the uselessness of the “unfit” and promoting societal acceptance
of forced sterilization of the feeble, disabled, and mentally ill. Rowan makes a best friend, Dorchy, and they
contrive a plan to run away together.
But the organization Dorchy works for tracks them down, and ultimately
they go to work as camp counselors on an island in which there are mysterious
medical practices afoot. An influenza
outbreak at the camp could mean real peril for both campers and counselors, but
not for the reasons you may think.
I applaud this story for exposing the warped beliefs (now
completely discredited by genetic science) of the eugenics movement that was
gaining general support in the 20th century. The author gets carried away and takes things
to an unbelievable level in the second half of the book, which I feel detracts
greatly. The book toggles back and forth
between present time and reminiscences, and there are some puzzling scenes and
characters that don’t have enough depth or explanation. We get more description of the smell of the
seaside than we do some of the characters.
HS – OPTIONAL Reviewer:
JA, High School Librarian
No comments:
Post a Comment