Content: G
BUYING ADVISORY: MS - ADVISABLE
AUDIENCE APPEAL: HIGH
Ash and their mother have moved across town to a more inclusive middle school, after Ash was physically assaulted in their previous school and video was posted all over the Internet. Right now Ash is presenting as a girl, but moving towards a more male outlook. Then they see Daniel – a very cute boy that flutters Ash’s heart and they decide to present female for as long as possible as they become closer to Daniel. Daniel, meanwhile, finds Ash interesting, but he also has a big secret – a big problem. He has rescued an aged Pomeranian that pees uncontrollably. He is hoping that his adult co-worker will return in time to save the poor dog. Meanwhile, Daniel is hiding the dog in a tent in the woods as winter is starting to arrive.
Machlas skillfully introduces us to Ash and their family and showcases the many intricate relationships that Ash is trying to navigate. While Daniel’s story adds some comedy, I found it way too distracting for me. Daniel could be shown as a person with many dimensions without being such an over-the-top problem. I loved how one of the students in the GSA (Gay-Straight Alliance) addresses everyone as “Themdies and Gentlethems”. An excellent look into gender fluidity from the perspective of the person, instead of an outsider looking in. Ash presents as white.
Cindy, Library Teacher, MLS
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment