Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Mystery James Returns From the Grave (Mystery James #2) by Ally Russell - OPTIONAL

Mystery James Returns From the Grave (Mystery James #2) by Ally Russell, 304 pages. Delacorte Press (Random House), 2026. $18

Violence: PG-13 (supernatural horror & suspense)

BUYING ADVISORY: MS - OPTIONAL

APPEALS TO: SOME

13yo Mystery James is looking forward to sleeping in and hanging out with her best friend Garret over spring break. However, Garret keeps canceling plans with Mystery, and he’s not the only one acting odd. Tía Lucy seems almost possessed some days, two creepy salesmen selling casket insurance keep lurking around, and Mystery keeps having the same nightmare of being buried alive. Could it all be related to the new poltergeist who made its home at Garcia Graves & Funeral Home?

I felt one of Russell’s strengths in the first Mystery James was revealing just enough of the mystery to keep readers turning pages without giving away too much. The second book in this duology seemed a bit more predictable. I wasn’t surprised by the ending, but it tied up some points from book one nicely. I enjoyed revisiting Ellis Town and its cast of characters.

The characters are black and brown

E. Powell, Junior High Librarian



No comments: