Language: PG (9 swears, 0 ‘f'); Mature Content: PG-13 (rape, brief descriptions and language used to briefly mention sexual paintings; Violence: PG (peril from supernatural sources)
BUYING ADVISORY: MS - OPTIONAL; HS - ADVISABLE
APPEALS TO: SEVERAL
It's 1921. Four 15yo debutantes are invited to spend a weekend at Greystone Manor in rural New Hampshire for the chance to compete against each other and become the heiress to the multi-million dollar estate. Each girl comes with a different motivation. Dorothea wants to find out what happened to her mother that disappeared here; Elspeth was sent by her mother to save her family from financial ruin; Vaughn is pampered and spoiled and determined to win the inheritance; and Birdie is a polio survivor and just wants an adventure. The manor is dark, mysterious, and menacing. Dorothea, Elspeth, and Birdie form a friendship, but Vaughn stays aloof as she feels she is above the others. As each debutante encounters strange and supernatural events and rooms in the manor, they quickly realize that the Manor keeps its victims and that they will not be able to escape. A monster lurks behind the walls and in the bowels of the Manor.
McWilliams has created engaging characters with the chapters alternating between the different characters and their experiences, both from their past and in the present at the Manor. This was a Gothic Horror genre, which is not my typical choice of genre; I was happy to see that it was not too creepy, but creepy and weird enough for those lovers of the Horror genre. The final showdown between the characters and the force of evil was intelligently handled and satisfying, especially for those who like an ending with resolution. The novel also had thought-provoking ideas on society and human nature that did not have any agenda attached. As an English teacher, I was also happy to see great vocabulary word building. The one negative I would say is that there were shocking descriptions of paintings of a sexual nature, somewhat perverted, in one of the bedrooms. The description was brief and not dwelt upon. Afterward, the pictures were called 'filthy paintings' by the characters. Personally, I thought this particular detail was totally unnecessary and did not have any connection to the storyline. Considering this is aimed at Middle School and High School youth, the painting descriptions should have been left out completely. 4.5 out of 5 stars.
Rebecca Jo Hansen, HS Language Arts teacher
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment